| All-NESCAC |
Player of the Year |
Defensive Player of the Year |
Rookie of the Year |
Coaching Staff of the Year |
| 2025 |
Jack Regnery (Jr., A), Tufts |
Jed Hoggard (Sr., D), Bowdoin |
Willie Doyle (M), Amherst |
Bowdoin (Bill Mason) |
| 2024 |
Will Byrne (Jr., A), Bowdoin |
Jack Fried (Jr., G), Hamilton |
Brendan Reilly (A), Amherst |
Wesleyan (John Raba) |
| 2023 |
Jack Boyden (Sr., A), Tufts |
|
Bob Gross (A), Amherst |
Casey D'Annolfo, Tufts |
| 2022 |
Donal Mullane (Sr., A), Bowdoin |
|
Will Byrne (A), Bowdoin |
Bill Mason, Bowdoin |
| 2021 |
Mac Bredhal (Jr., A), Tufts |
|
Pearse Glavin (A), Williams |
George McCormack, Williams |
| 2020 |
Championship was not held due to COVID-19 |
| 2019 |
Evan Wolf (Sr., A), Amherst |
|
Jake Hasse (M), Williams |
George McCormack, Williams |
| 2018 |
Evan Wolf (Jr., A), Amherst |
|
Ronan Jacoby (A), Wesleyan |
Jon Thompson, Amherst |
| 2017 |
Charlie Fay (Sr., A), Bates |
|
Colin Minicus (A), Amherst |
John Raba, Wesleyan |
| 2016 |
John Uppgren (Sr., A), Tufts |
|
Clayton Wright (A), Bowdoin |
Jason Archbell, Bowdoin |
| 2015 |
Quinn Moroney (Jr., A), Amherst |
|
Harry Stanton (A), Wesleyan |
Peter Lasagna, Bates
Jon Thompson, Amherst |
| 2014 |
Cole Bailey (Jr., A), Tufts |
|
Austin Sayre (A), Colby |
Mike Daly, Tufts
George McCormack, Williams |
| 2013 |
Ian Deveau (Sr., M), Colby |
|
Jon Broome (A), Middlebury |
Peter Lasagna, Bates |
| 2012 |
Jon Leanos (Sr., A), Hamilton |
|
Cole Bailey (A), Tufts |
Tom McCabe, Bowdoin |
| 2011 |
DJ Hessler (Sr., A), Tufts |
|
Devin Acton (A), Amherst |
Michael Higgins, Trinity |
| 2010 |
DJ Hessler (Jr., A), Tufts |
|
Ian Deveau (M), Colby |
Dave Cornell, Conn. College |
| 2009 |
Mike Stone (Sr., M), Middlebury |
|
John Froats (M), Wesleyan |
Dave Campbell, Middlebury |
| 2008 |
Mike Stone (Jr., M), Middlebury |
|
David Hawley (A), Williams |
George McCormack, Williams |
| 2007 |
Derek Cherney (Sr., A), Amherst |
|
Jon Killeen (A), Wesleyan |
Mike Daly, Tufts |
| 2006 |
Connor Fitzgerald (Sr., A), Bowdoin |
|
Caddy Brooks (A), Colby |
John Raba, Wesleyan |
| 2005 |
Derek Cherney (So., A), Amherst |
|
Jim Cabrera (A), Middlebury |
Peter Lasagna, Bates |
| 2004 |
Bryan Griffin (Jr., A) Tufts |
|
Derek Cherney (A), Amherst |
Mike Daly, Tufts |
| 2003 |
Bryan Griffin (So., A), Tufts |
|
Glen Adams (M), Wesleyan |
Erin Quinn, Middlebury |
| 2002 |
Matt Dunn (Sr., M), Middlebury |
|
Bryan Griffin (A), Tufts |
Rob Quinn, Colby |
| 2001 |
John Landay (Sr., A), Wesleyan |
|
Tony Aleandre (D), Trinity |
John Raba, Wesleyan |
