| All-NESCAC |
Player of the Year |
Pitcher of the Year |
Defensive Player of the Year |
Rookie of the Year |
Coach of the Year |
| 2025 |
Kyle McCausland (Sr., OF), Middlebury |
Ryan Grecco (Sr.), Colby
Owen McHugh (So.), Williams |
Ryan McIntyre (Sr., IF), Amherst |
Myles Gythfeldt (IF), Colby |
Mike Leonard, Middlebury |
| 2024 |
Cole Palmeri (Sr., C), Colby |
Justin Lessing (Jr.), Middlebury |
Malcolm Whitfield (So., C/OF), Tufts |
Malachi Pena (OF), Tufts |
Mike Leonard, Middlebury |
| 2023 |
Kyle McCausland (So., OF), Middlebury |
Alex Price (Sr.), Middlebury |
Ozzie Fleischer (Jr., SS), Tufts |
Ernie Little (IF), Wesleyan |
Paul Svagdis, Tufts |
| 2022 |
Alec Ritch (Jr., OF), Middlebury |
George Goldstein (Sr.), Middlebury |
Cole Palmeri (So., C), Colby |
CJ Brito-Trinidad (IF), Bowdoin |
Mike Leonard, Middlebury |
| 2021 |
Daniel Qin (Jr., OF), Amherst |
Michael Volegrande (Jr.), Tufts |
Christian Beal (Sr., OF), Bates |
Nick Giattino (P), Amherst |
JP Pyne, Amherst |
| 2020 |
Championship not held due to COVID-19 |
| 2019 |
Doug Schaffer (Sr., IF), Williams |
R.J. Hall (Sr.), Tufts |
Jack Arend (Jr., C), Bates
Kellen Hatheway (Sr., IF), Williams |
Peter DeMaria (UT), Tufts |
Jon Martin, Bates |
| 2018 |
Malcolm Nachmanoff (Sr., OF), Tufts |
Colby Morris (Jr.), Middlebury |
Brooks Carroll (So., IF), Middlebury |
Matt Zaffino (IF), Hamilton |
Brian Hamm, Amherst |
| 2017 |
Nick Falkson (Jr., IF), Tufts |
Speros Varinos (Sr.), Tufts |
Kellen Hatheway (So., IF), Williams |
Alex Rodriguez (C), Trinity
John Lamont (P), Williams |
John Casey, Tufts |
| 2016 |
Marco Baratta (Sr., RF), Wesleyan |
Speros Varinos (Jr.), Tufts |
Scott Cullinan (Sr., C), Trinity |
Kellen Hatheway (SS), Williams |
John Casey, Tufts |
| 2015 |
Mike Odenwaelder (Jr., OF), Amherst |
Sam Elias (Sr.), Wesleyan |
Connor McDavitt (Sr., CF), Tufts |
Tommy O'Hara (3B), Tufts |
Mark Woodworth, Wesleyan |
| 2014 |
Mike Odenwaelder (So., OF), Amherst |
Kyle Slinger (Jr.), Tufts |
Connor McDavitt (Jr., CF), Tufts |
Tim Superko (P), Tufts |
Mark Woodworth, Wesleyan |
| 2013 |
Joe Papa (Sr., 1B), Trinity |
Bob Cook (Sr.), Amherst |
Taiki Kasuga (Jr., SS), Amherst |
Mike Odenwaelder (OF), Amherst |
Mark Woodworth, Wesleyan |
| 2012 |
Bob Cook (Jr., P/1B), Amherst |
Oliver Van Zant (Jr.), Bowdoin |
Mike Samela (Sr., C/OF), Amherst |
Sean Meekins (P), Trinity |
Mike Connolly, Bowdoin |
| 2011 |
Mike Samela (Jr., C), Amherst |
Ed Bernstein (Sr.), Tufts |
Matt Collins (Jr., C), Tufts |
Christian Martin (P), Bowdoin |
Brian Hamm, Amherst |
| 2010 |
Al Matthews (Sr., OF), Williams
James Wood (Sr., OF), Trinity |
Oliver Van Zant (Fy.), Bowdoin |
Alex Perry (Sr., C), Tufts |
Oliver Van Zant (P), Bowdoin |
John Casey, Amherst |
| 2009 |
Sean Kileen (Sr., C), Trinity |
Jeremiah Bayer (Sr.), Trinity |
Kent Graham (Jr., 1B), Trinity |
Kevin Heller (OF), Amherst |
Bill Decker, Trinity |
| 2008 |
Steve Ragonese (Sr., IF), Tufts |
Tim Kiely (Sr.), Trinity |
|
Chase Rose (OF/DH), Tufts |
Bill Decker, Trinity |
| 2007 |
Noah Walker (Sr., SS), Middlebury |
Tim Kiely (Jr.), Trinity |
|
Robin Allemand (3B), Williams
Kent Graham (1B), Trinity |
Bill Barrale, Williams |
| 2006 |
Chris Kenney (Jr., C), Williams |
Joe Vladeck (Sr.), Amherst |
|
Dan Benz (P), Williams |
Bob Smith, Middlebury |
| 2005 |
Jeff Natale (Sr., 3B), Trinity |
Joe Vladeck (Jr.), Amherst |
|
Nick Spillance (OF), Colby |
Bill Decker, Trinity |
| 2004 |
Jabe Bergeron (Sr., 1B), Williams |
Mark Tremblay (Jr.), Trinity |
|
Brian Donahue (P), Amherst |
Mike Connelly, Bowdoin |
| 2003 |
Kurt Piantek (Sr., 2B), Trinity |
Jon Lee (Sr.), Tufts |
|
Jared Lemeiux (CF), Bowdoin |
Bill Decker, Trinity |
| 2002 |
Mark Scialabba (Sr., DH), Williams |
Jonah Bayliss (Jr.), Trinity |
|
Chris Bodnar (P), Williams |
Mark Woodworth, Wesleyan |
| 2001 |
Dan Callahan (Jr., OF), Tufts |
Jon Lee (So.), Tufts |
|
Jabe Bergeron (1B), Williams |
Dave Barnard, Williams |
