| 2024 |
Luke Madden (Sr., D), Middlebury |
Max Clivio (Gr., D), Tufts |
Keagan Harder (M), Middlebury |
Tufts (Kyle Dezotell) |
| 2023 |
Ada Okorogheye (Sr., F), Amherst |
Ryan Grady (Sr., G), Middlebury |
Mohammed Nuhu (F), Amherst |
Middlebury (Alex Elias) |
| 2022 |
Dylan Reid (Sr., D), Bowdoin |
|
Tyler Huck (M) Bowdoin |
Scott Wiercinski, Bowdoin |
| 2021 |
Augie Djerdjaj (Jr., M), Conn. College |
|
Ethan Franco (F), Colby |
Geoff Wheeler, Wesleyan |
| 2020 |
None Declared - 2020 Season was canceled due to COVID-19 |
| 2019 |
German Giammattei (So., F), Amherst |
|
Ryan Grady (GK), Middlebury |
Josh Shapiro, Tufts |
| 2018 |
A.J. Marcucci (So., GK), Conn. College |
|
German Giammattei (F), Amherst |
Kenny Murphy, Conn. College |
| 2017 |
Conor Coleman (Sr., D), Tufts |
|
A.J. Marcucci (GK), Conn. College |
Josh Shapiro, Tufts |
| 2016 |
Pat Devlin (Sr., M), Conn. College |
|
Luke Eckels (D), Hamilton |
Perry Nizzi, Hamilton |
| 2015 |
Nabil Odulate (Sr., D), Bowdoin |
|
Mark Leon (F), Conn. College |
Scott Wiercinski, Bowdoin
David Saward, Middlebury |
| 2014 |
Greg Conrad (So., F), Middlebury |
|
Adam Cowie-Haskell (F), Wesleyan |
Josh Shapiro, Tufts |
| 2013 |
Billy Hawkey (Sr., F), Conn. College |
|
Adam Glaser (F), Middlebury |
Justin Serpone, Amherst |
| 2012 |
Adam Purdy (Sr., GK), Wesleyan |
|
Mohammed Rashid (F), Williams |
Mike Russo, Williams |
| 2011 |
Spencer Noon (Jr., F), Amherst |
|
Gus Santos (F), Tufts |
Mike Pilger, Trinity |
| 2010 |
Harrison Watkins (Sr., D), Middlebury |
|
Ben Brewster (D), Bowdoin |
Fran O'Leary, Bowdoin |
| 2009 |
Conor Smith (Sr., D), Williams |
|
Adam Purdy (GK), Wesleyan |
Geoff Wheeler, Wesleyan |
| 2008 |
Brian Bush (Sr., GK), Middlebury |
|
Tyler Macnee (F), Middlebury |
David Saward, Middlebury |
| 2007 |
Nick Figueiredo (Sr., F), Bowdoin |
|
Ben Denton-Schneider (M), Bowdoin |
Mike Pilger, Trinity |
| 2006 |
Patrick Huffer (Sr., F), Williams |
|
Matt Lewis (M), Amherst |
Mike Russo, Williams |
| 2005 |
Josh Bolton (Sr., M), Williams |
|
Matt Nevin (M), Wesleyan |
Geoff Wheeler, Wesleyan |
| 2004 |
Josh Bolton (Jr., M), Williams |
|
David LaRocca (F), Middlebury |
George Purgavie, Bates |
| 2003 |
Khari Stephenson (Sr., M), Williams |
|
Brett Olsen (F), Williams |
Mike Russo, Williams |
| 2002 |
Khari Stephenson (Jr., M), Williams |
|
Joseph Gannon (F), Amherst |
Mike Russo, Williams |
| 2001 |
Alex Blake (Jr., F), Williams |
|
Andrew Syfu (D), Amherst |
Ralph Ferrigno, Tufts |
| 2000 |
Alex Blake (So., F), Williams |
|
Franklin Perry (F), Amherst |
Mike Russo, Williams |
