| All-NESCAC |
Player of the Year |
Defensive Player of the Year * |
Rookie of the Year |
Coach of the Year |
| 2025 |
Luke Tchor (So., F), Hamilton |
Charlie Archer (Sr., G), Hamilton |
Ty Broad (F), Trinity |
Rob Haberbusch, Hamilton |
| 2024 |
Devon Bobak (So., G), Trinity |
Ned Blanchard (Sr., D), Trinity |
Luke Tchor (F), Hamilton |
Matthew Greason, Trinity |
| 2023 |
Jake Lachance (Sr., D), Wesleyan |
|
Ben Zimmerman (F), Hamilton |
Chris Potter, Wesleyan |
| 2022 |
Lucas Michaud (Sr., F), Trinity |
|
Jack Sullivan (D), Colby |
Blaise MacDonald, Colby |
| 2021 |
None Declared - 2020-21 Season was canceled due to COVID-19 |
| 2020 |
Barclay Gammill (Sr., F), Trinity |
|
Evan Ruschil (G), Williams |
Bill Kangas, Williams |
| 2019 |
Tim Sestak (Jr., G), Wesleyan |
|
Lucas Michaud (F), Trinity |
Chris Potter, Wesleyan |
| 2018 |
Connor Rodericks (So., G), Conn. College |
|
Paul Capozzi (F), Conn. College |
Jim Ward, Conn. College |
| 2017 |
Evan Buitenhuis (Jr., G), Hamilton |
|
Walker Harris (F), Wesleyan |
Rob Haberbusch, Hamilton |
| 2016 |
Zander Masucci (Sr., D), Williams |
|
Michael Pinios (G), Williams
Cody Todesco (F), Bowdoin |
Bill Kangas, Williams |
| 2015 |
Ryan Cole (So., F), Trinity |
|
David White (F), Amherst |
Jack Arena, Amherst |
| 2014 |
Jackson Brewer (Jr., F), Trinity |
|
Ryan Cole (F), Trinity |
Jim Ward, Conn. College |
| 2013 |
Keith Buehler (Jr., F), Wesleyan |
|
Matt Silcoff (F), Middlebury |
Matt Greason, Trinity |
| 2012 |
Jonathan La Rose (Sr., G), Amherst |
|
John McGinnis (F), Bowdoin |
Brian Murhphy, Tufts |
| 2011 |
Joe Houk (So., D), Hamilton |
|
Michael DiMare (F), Hamilton |
Norm Bazin, Hamilton |
| 2010 |
Alex Smigelski (Sr., F), Williams |
|
Daniel Weiniger (F), Bowdoin |
Norm Bazin, Hamilton |
| 2009 |
Jeff Landers (Sr., D), Amherst |
|
Martin Drolet (F), Middlebury |
Jack Arena, Amherst |
| 2008 |
T.J. Kelley (Sr., F), Colby |
|
Ryan Leary (F), Bowdoin |
Jim Tortorella, Colby |
| 2007 |
Greg Osborne (Sr., F), Colby |
|
Greg Parker (G), Conn. College |
Chris Potter, Wesleyan |
| 2006 |
Gus Katsuras (Sr., F), Hamilton |
|
Dallas Bossort (D), Wesleyan |
Bill Kangas, Williams
Jim Tortorella, Colby |
| 2005 |
Gus Katsuras (Jr., F), Hamilton |
|
Kyle Schoppel (F), Amherst |
John Dunham, Trinity |
| 2004 |
Kevin Cooper (Sr., F), Middlebury |
|
Will Bennett (F), Wesleyan |
Chris Potter, Wesleyan |
| 2003 |
Kevin Cooper (Jr., F), Middlebury |
|
Adam Dann (F), Bowdoin
Gabe Tash (G), Hamilton |
John Dunham, Trinity |
| 2002 |
Mike Carosi (Sr., F), Bowdoin |
|
Beau Kretzman (F), Amherst |
Terry Meagher, Bowdoin |
| 2001 |
Jim Smith (Sr., D), Amherst |
|
Adam Foote (F), Middlebury |
John Dunham, Trinity |
| 2000 |
Curt Goldman (Sr., F), Middlebury |
|
Sean O'Grady (D), Colby |
Dave Snyder, Wesleyan |
