| All-NESCAC |
Player of the Year |
Defensive Player of the Year |
Rookie of the Year |
Coach of the Year * |
| 2025 |
Hank Morgan (Sr., G), Hamilton |
Jarrel Okorougo (Jr., G/F), Trinity |
Ray Cuevas (G), Bowdoin |
Wesleyan (Joe Reilly and Staff) |
| 2024 |
David Murray (Sr., F/C), Connecticut College |
Dana Smith (Gr., F),
Trinity |
Marc Begin II (G), Bates |
Trinity (James Cosgrove and Staff) |
| 2023 |
Alex Sobel (Sr., F), Middlebury |
Alex Sobel (Sr., F), Middlebury |
Henry Vetter (G), Trinity |
Adam Stockwell, Hamilton |
| 2022 |
Sam Peek (Sr., G), Wesleyan |
Nick Osarenren (Sr., G), Hamilton |
Sam Stevens (G), Middlebury |
Joe Reilly, Wesleyan |
| 2021 |
None Declared - 2020-21 Season was canceled due to COVID-19 |
| 2020 |
Luke Rogers (Jr., F), Tufts |
Kyle Padmore (Sr., G), Trinity |
Will King (G), Colby |
Bob Sheldon, Tufts |
| 2019 |
Kena Gilmour (Jr., G), Hamilton |
Jordan Bonner (Sr., G), Wesleyan |
Noah Tyson (G), Colby |
David Hixon, Amherst |
| 2018 |
James Heskett (Jr., G), Williams |
Jordan Sears (Sr., G), Wesleyan |
Austin Hutcherson (G), Wesleyan |
Adam Stockwell, Hamilton |
| 2017 |
Matt St. Amour (Sr., G), Middlebury |
Malcolm Delpeche (Sr., F), Bates |
Kena Gilmour (G), Hamilton |
Jeff Brown, Middlebury |
| 2016 |
Shay Ajayi (Sr., F), Trinity |
Ed Ogundecko (Jr., F), Trinity |
Jack Simonds (F), Bowdoin |
Jeff Brown, Middlebury |
| 2015 |
Lucas Hausman (Jr., G), Bowdoin |
John Swords (Sr. C), Bowdoin |
Johnny McCarthy (G), Amherst |
James Cosgrove, Trinity |
| 2014 |
Aaron Toomey (Sr., G), Amherst |
John Swords (Jr., C), Bowdoin |
Duncan Robinson (F), Williams |
David Hixon, Amherst |
| 2013 |
Aaron Toomey (Jr., G) |
Nolan Thompson (Sr., G), Middlebury |
Tom Palleschi (C), Tufts |
David Hixon, Amherst |
| 2012 |
Ryan Sharry (Sr., F), Middlebury |
Willy Workman (Jr., F), Amherst |
Ben Ferris (G), Tufts |
Jeff Brown, Middlebury |
| 2011 |
Troy Whittington (Sr., C), Williams |
Andrew Locke (Sr., C), Middlebury |
Aaron Toomey (G), Amherst |
Jeff Brown, Middlebury |
| 2010 |
Blake Schultz (Sr., F), Williams |
Tim Edwards (Sr., G), Middlebury |
Shasha Brown (G), Wesleyan |
Mike Maker, Williams |
| 2009 |
Ben Rudin (Sr., G), Middlebury |
Tim Edwards (Jr., G), Middlebury |
Demetrius Porter (F), Conn. College |
Jeff Brown, Middlebury |
| 2008 |
Andrew Olson (Sr., G), Amherst |
Aaron Westbrooks (Jr., F), Trinity |
Brian Ellis (F), Bates |
Tim Gilbride, Bowdoin |
| 2007 |
Andrew Olson (Jr. G), Amherst |
Zak Ray (Sr., G), Bates |
Jon Pierce (F), Tufts |
Dave Paulsen, Williams |
| 2006 |
Tyler Rhoten (Sr., F), Trinity |
Drew Cohen (Jr., C), Colby |
Ben Rudin (G), Middlebury |
Joe Reilly, Bates |
| 2005 |
Andrew Schiel (Sr., C/F), Amherst |
Jaris Cole (Sr., G), Williams |
Andrew Olson (G), Amherst
Charles Stone (C), Conn. College |
David Hixon, Amherst |
| 2004 |
Ben Coffin (Sr., F), Williams |
Adam Harper (Sr., G), Amherst |
Zak Ray (G), Bates
Robert Taylor (F), Trinity |
Dave Paulsen, Williams |
| 2003 |
Steve Zieja (Sr., F), Amherst |
Adam Harper (Jr., G), Amherst |
Tyler Rhoden (F), Trinity |
Dave Paulsen, Williams |
| 2002 |
Colin Tabb (Sr., G), Trinity |
Mizan Ayers (Sr., G), Conn. College |
Craig Coupe (C), Tufts |
Lynn Ramage, Conn. College |
| 2001 |
Sam Clark (Sr. F), Colby |
Andrew Conley (Sr., G), Williams |
Phil Barlow (G), Tufts
Mike Crotty (G), Williams |
David Hixon, Amherst |
