| All-NESCAC |
Player of the Year |
Pitcher of the Year |
Defensive Player of the Year |
Rookie of the Year |
Coach of the Year |
| 2025 |
Sydney Fleming (Sr., C), Williams |
Sadie Leonard (Jr.), Williams |
Anika Ewert (Jr., OF), Bowdoin |
Jacelyn Lees (P), Wesleyan |
Wesleyan (Jen Lane) |
| 2024 |
Anika Ewert (So., OF), Bowdoin |
Sadie Leonard (So.), Williams |
Josie Steinberg (Sr., UT), Tufts |
Katie Blanch (P/1B), Williams |
Middlebury (Kelly Bevere) |
| 2023 |
Angelina Mayers (Sr., OF), Bowdoin
Rachel Moore (Sr., UT), Tufts |
Sadie Leonard (Fy.), Williams |
Jose Steinberg (Sr., UT), Tufts |
Emilie Doty (P), Tufts
Sadie Leonard (P), Williams |
Kat McKay, Bates
Teren Allen, Colby |
| 2022 |
Noelle Ruschil (Sr., IF), Middlebury |
Sophia DiCocco (So.), Tufts |
Jose Steinberg (Jr., UT), Tufts |
Taylor Mikolajczak (IF), Trinity |
Molly Rathbun, Trinity |
| 2021 |
Kirstin Mapes (Sr., P), Williams |
Kristian Haghdan (Sr.), Tufts |
Emma Della Vlope (Sr., IF), Tufts |
Sophia DiCocco (P), Tufts |
Lauren Ebstein, Tufts |
| 2020 |
Championship not held due to COVID-19 |
| 2019 |
MElanie Mandell (Jr., OF), Middlebury |
Kristi Van Meter (So. Tufts) |
Jessica Kim (Sr., SS), Williams |
Mara Kipnis (UT), Williams |
Stephanie Hartquist, Hamilton |
| 2018 |
Lexi Curt (Sr., C), Williams |
Rebecca Duncan (So.), Williams) |
Claire McCathy (Sr., C), Bowdoin |
Kristi Van Meter (P), Tufts |
Ryan Sullivan, Bowdoin |
| 2017 |
Lexi Curt (Jr., C/IF), Williams |
Gina Pagan (Jr.), Amherst |
Sammy Salustri (So., 2B), Amherst |
Rebecca Duncan (P), Williams |
Caitlin Hitchcock, Trinity |
| 2016 |
Erica Li (Sr., OF), Williams |
Mackenzie Murphy (Fy.), Williams |
Sammy Salustri (Fy., 2B), Amherst |
Caroline Rice (OF), Bowdoin |
Caitlin Hitchcock, Trinity |
| 2015 |
Julia Geaumont (Jr., P/DP), Bowdoin
Cassie Ruscz (So., 1B), Tufts |
Allyson Fournier (Sr.), Tufts |
Michelle Cooprider (Sr., CF), Tufts |
Raven Fournier (C/FP), Tufts |
Cheryl Milligan, Tufts |
| 2014 |
Jo Clair (Sr., C), Tufts |
Allyson Fournier (Jr.), Tufts |
Christina Raso (So., SS), Tufts |
Abby Rutt (C/SS), Wesleyan |
Cheryl Milligan, Tufts |
| 2013 |
Allee Beatty (Sr., OF/C), Wesleyan |
Allyson Fournier (So.), Tufts |
Allee Beatty (Sr., OF/C), Wesleyan |
Su Pardo (P), Wesleyan |
Cheryl Milligan, Tufts |
| 2012 |
Allison Hart (Sr., OF), Williams |
Allyson Fournier (Fy.), Tufts |
Jessa Hoffman (Jr., SS), Middlebury |
Allyson Fournier (P), Tufts |
Cheryl Milligan, Tufts |
| 2011 |
Lena Cantone (Jr., 1B), Tufts |
Geena Constantin (Sr.), Middlebury |
Caroline Blanchard (So., SS), Trinity |
Jo Clair (C), Tufts |
Kelly Bevere, Middlebury |
| 2010 |
Casey Sullivan (Sr., SS), Tufts |
Kara Nilan (Jr.), Bowdoin |
Casey Sullivan (Sr., SS), Tufts |
Cedar Blazek (OF), Williams |
Jen Lane, Wesleyan |
| 2009 |
Joey Lye (Sr., SS), Williams |
Lauren Gelmetti (Sr.), Tufts |
Laura Chapman (Sr., OF), Tufts |
Carly Dudzik (SS), Amherst |
Cheryl Milligan, Tufts |
| 2008 |
Christy Tinker (So., 1B), Tufts |
Meghan Dendy (So.), Wesleyan |
|
Izzie Santone (P), Tufts |
Cheryl Milligan, Tufts
Jen Lane, Wesleyan |
| 2007 |
Sara Dougherty (Sr., P/1B), Trinity |
Sara Dogherty (Sr.), Trinity |
|
Casey Sullivan (2B/SS), Tufts |
Cheryl Milligan, Tufts |
| 2006 |
Danielle Lopez (So., 2B), Tufts |
Clara Hard (Sr.), Williams |
|
Stacia Saniuk (C/3B), Bates |
Kris Herman, Williams |
| 2005 |
Courtney Bongiolatti (Sr., SS), Tufts |
Clara Hard (Jr.), Williams |
|
Danielle Lopez (2B), Tufts |
Cheryl Milligan, Tufts |
| 2004 |
Katie Smith (Jr., 1B), Tufts |
Clara Hard (So.), Williams |
|
Emily Nelson (P), Bowdoin |
Kris Herman, Williams |
| 2003 |
Lis Drake (Sr., C), Tufts |
Lauren Olmsted (Fy.), Colby |
|
Alana Frost (SS), Williams |
Kris Herman, Tufts |
| 2002 |
Jen Mackey (Sr., SS), Tufts |
Jodie Moreau (Sr.), Tufts |
|
Courtney Bongiolatti (OF), Tufts |
Kris Herman, Tufts |
| 2001 |
Randee McArdle (Sr., OF), Tufts |
Lauren Peloquin (Jr.), Amherst |
|
Erin Hanley (P), Bowdoin
Gina Scribner (1B), Amherst |
Kris Herman, Tufts |
