| 2024 |
Chase Wilson (Sr., WR), Wesleyan |
Ben Carbeau (Sr., LB), Wesleyan |
Jack Nye (Fy., WR), Colby |
Wesleyan (Dan DiCenzo) |
| 2023 |
Spencer Fetter (Gr., QB), Trinity
Jaden Richardson (Sr., WR), Tufts |
Tomás Kenary (Sr., DL), Middlebury |
Luke Kurzum (Fy., QB), Hamilton |
Middlebury (Doug Mandigo) |
| 2022 |
Phil Lutz (Sr., WR), Tufts |
Nick Helbig (Sr., DL), Wesleyan |
Tyler DiNapoli (RB), Tufts |
Jeff Devanney, Trinity |
| 2021 |
Bobby Maimaron (Sr., QB), Williams |
Nick Helbig (Jr., DL), Wesleyan |
Andre Eden (RB), Bowdoin
Tomas Kenary (DL), Middlebury |
Mark Raymond, Williams |
| 2020 |
None Declared - 2020 Season was canceled due to COVID-19 |
|
| 2019 |
Will Jernigan (Jr., QB), Middlebury |
Jack Pistorius (Jr., LB), Middlebury |
Alex Maldjian (RB), Middlebury
Nick Helbig (DL), Wesleyan |
Bob Ritter, Middlebury |
| 2018 |
Max Chipouras (Sr., RB), Trinity
Ryan McDonald (Sr., QB), Tufts |
Andrew Yamin (Sr., DE), Amherst |
Matt Hersch (QB), Colby
Seamus Lambert (QB), Trinity |
Jeff Devanny, Trinity |
| 2017 |
Mike Breuler (Sr., WR), Wesleyan |
Andrew Yamin (Jr., DE), Amherst |
Bobby Maimaron (QB), Williams |
Mark Raymond, Williams |
| 2016 |
Chance Brady (Sr., RB), Tufts |
Spencer Donahue (Sr., LB), Trinity |
Greg Holt (LB), Tufts |
Jeff Devanny, Trinity |
| 2015 |
Chance Brady (Jr., RB), Tufts |
Jimmy Fairfield-Sonn (Sr., DB), Amherst |
Max Chipouras (RB), Trinity |
E.J. Mills, Amherst |
| 2014 |
Matt Milano (Jr., QB) Middlebury |
Jake Bussani (Gr., DB), Wesleyan |
Chris Simmons (OL), Trinity |
E.J. Mills, Amherst |
| 2013 |
McCallum Foote (Sr., QB), Middlebury |
Joe Cleary (Sr., LB), Bowdoin |
Sonny Puzzo (QB), Trinity |
Bob Ritter, Middlebury |
| 2012 |
McCallum Foote (Jr., QB), Middlebury |
Rae Haynes (Sr., FS), Trinity |
Tim Patricia (LB), Middlebury |
Jeff Devanney, Trinity
Mark Harriman, Bates |
| 2011 |
Eric Bunker (Sr., RB), Amherst |
Walter Fallas (Sr., LB), Trinity |
LaDarius Drew (RB), Wesleyan |
E.J. Mills, Amherst |
| 2010 |
Patrick Moffitt (Sr., QB), Williams |
Walter Fallas (Jr., LB), Trinity |
Evan Bunker (RB), Trinity |
Aaron Kelton, Williams |
| 2009 |
Donald McKillop (Jr., QB), Middlebury |
Michael Taylor (Sr., LB), Amherst |
Chris Cameron (LB), Williams |
E.J. Mills, Amherst |
| 2008 |
Eric McGrath (Sr., QB), Trinity |
Tyler Berry (Sr., LB), Trinity |
Donnie Simmons (DL), Tufts |
Jeff Devanny, Trinity |
| 2007 |
Patrick Lucey (Sr., QB), Williams |
Erik Woodring (Sr., LB), Middlebury |
Donald McKillop (QB), Middlebury |
Bob Ritter, Middlebury |
| 2006 |
Patrick Lucey (Jr., QB), Williams |
Mike Soules (Sr., DB), Trinity |
John Lawrence (RB/LB), Hamilton |
Mike Whelan, Williams |
| 2005 |
Mark Hannon (Jr., WR), Amherst |
Michael Blair (Sr., DL), Trinity |
None Selected |
Chuck Priore, Trinity |
| 2004* |
Fletcher Ladd (Sr., RB), Amherst |
Aaron Goldstein (Sr., DB), Trinity |
Brandon Colon (QB), Bates
Adam Arsenault (LB), Tufts |
Chuck Priore, Trinity |
| 2003* |
Tom Pierandri (Sr., RB), Trinity |
Graham Goldwasser (Sr., LB), Williams |
Ken Adams (RB), Bates
Scott Secor (DB), Middlebury |
Chuck Priore, Trinity |
| 2002* |
Joe Reardon (Jr., QB), Williams |
Scott Farley (Sr., P), Williams |
Pat Curran (RB), Wesleyan
Michael Blair (DL), Trinity |
Richard Farley, Williams |
| 2001* |
Joe Reardon (So., QB), Williams |
Pat McGee (Sr., DL), Amherst |
Aaron Stepka (RB), Colby
Peter Simon (DB), Hamilton |
Richard Farley, Williams |
| 2000* |
Bryan Sanchez (Sr., RB), Middlebury |
Andy Steele (Sr., LB), Middlebury |
Brennan Carney (QB), Wesleyan
Pat Foley (LB), Bates |
Tom Austin, Colby |
* From 2000-2004 an Offensive Rookie of the Year and Defensive Rookie of the Year were selected. The Defensive Rookie of the Year was discontinued after the 2004 season.
* In 2023 the Coach of the Year award was changed to Coaching Staff of the Year |
