All-Time Total: 53
- Amherst (10), Bates (1), Bowdoin (2), Colby (2), Middlebury (2), Trinity (20), Tufts (10), Wesleyan (3), Williams (3)
Most in a Single Season: 4 (2004)
Source: ABCA All-American Archive
 

Year	Name	Position	Institution	Team
1977	Nick Dell Erario	OF	Bates	Second Team
1977	Bill Swiacki	P	Amherst	Second Team
1978	Bill Swiacki	P	Amherst	First Team
1979	Paul Spillance	C	Colby	Second Team
1980	John Cerutti	P	Amherst	First Team
1980	Pete Martin	1B	Trinity	Third Team
1980	Mark Anderson	SS	Wesleyan	Third Team
1981	John Cerutti	P	Amherst	First Team
1981	Jack Schull	DH	Trinity	Second Team
1983	Mike Krueger	3B	Tufts	Second Team
1984	Kyle O'Brien	3B	Amherst	First Team
1984	John Nimons	P	Amherst	Second Team
1988	Tom Aldrich	UT	Bowdoin	Second Team
1988	Jim Duquette	OF	Williams	Third Team
1988	Jim Maynard	OF	Wesleyan	Third Team
1989	Mayo Noerdlinger	P	Amherst	Third Team
1991	Neal Huntington	1B	Amherst	Second Team
1991	Scott Pudio	P	Amherst	Second Team
1994	Craig Brewer	P	Wesleyan	Second Team
1996	Mike Ranieri	OF	Trinity	Third Team
1996	Jeff Taglienti	P	Tufts	Third Team
1997	Matt MacDonald	DH	Bowdoin	Second Team
1997	Jeff Taglienti	P	Tufts	Third Team
1998	Bo Edwards	OF	Trinity	Second Team
1998	Doug Grigar	C	Trinity	Third Team
1998	Dan Morse	OF	Tufts	Third Team
1999	Doug Grigar	C	Trinity	Third Team
2000	Bo Edwards	OF	Trinity	Second Team
2000	Kevin Downs	P	Amherst	Second Team
2000	Zack Brown	UR	Tufts	Third Team
2002	Jonah Bayloss	P	Trinity	Third Team
2003	Kurt Piantek	2B	Trinity	First Team
2003	Kevin Tidmarsh	P	Trinity	Second Team
2004	Jason Armstrong	SS	Trinity	First Team
2004	Jabe Bergeron	1B	Williams	Third Team
2004	Jeff Natale	2B	Trinity	Third Team
2004	Mike Frost	P	Trinity	Third Team
2005	Greg Talpey	P	Trinity	Third Team
2006	Chris Kenney	C	Williams	Second Team
2008	Tim Kiely	P	Trinity	First Team
2008	Chandler Barnard	UT	Trinity	First Team
2008	Jeremiah Bayer	P	Trinity	Second Team
2009	Sean Killeen	C	Trinity	First Team
2009	Jeremiah Bayer	P	Trinity	First Team
2010	James Wood	OF	Trinity	Second Team
2010	Chris DeGoti	P	Tufts	Third Team
2014	Kyle Slinger	P	Tufts	Second Team
2017	Speros Varinos	P	Tufts	Second Team
2019	RJ Hall	P	Tufts	Third Team
2024	Cole Palmeri	C	Colby	Fourth Team
2025	Kyle McCausland	OF	Middlebury	Second Team
2026	Henry Ayers	C	Middlebury	Third Team
2026	Cole Donato	P	Tufts	Third Team