Total: 31 honorees in 13 different sports
Breakdown by Institution: Amherst (1), Bowdoin (1), Colby (2), Middlebury (8), Trinity (1), Tufts (6), Wesleyan (4), Williams (7)
Breakdown by Sport: Men's Basketball (2), Women's Basketball (1), Field Hockey (2), Men's Lacrosse (5), Women's Lacrosse (6), Women's Rowing (3), Men's Soccer (3), Women's Soccer (1)
Men's Swimming & Diving  (1), Women's Swimming & Diving (1), Men's Tennis (4), Women's Tennis (1), Men's Track & Field (1)
Three-Time Winner: Hope Shue, Middlebury women's lacrosse (first Division III women's lacrosse player to win the award three times)
NCAA Elite Scholar-Athlete Award Database: click here

Year	Name	School	Sport	Major	GPA
2010	Liz Zhu	Williams College	Women's Rowing	Economics and Religion	3.90
2010	Nick Pugliese	Williams College	Men's Soccer	Political Science	4.00
2010	Sarah Cannon	Tufts University	Field Hockey	Mathematics	4.00
2011	Bryan Chow	Williams College	Men's Tennis	Political Science	4.00
2011	DJ Hessler	Tufts University	Men's Lacrosse	Biomedical Engineering	3.49
2011	Michael Gale	Bowdoin College	Men's Soccer	Undeclared	3.93
2011	Sean Hoffmann	Williams College	Men's Basketball	Political Science	3.78
2012	Bryan Chow	Williams College	Men's Tennis	Classics and Biology	3.94
2013	Alice Pfeifer	Middlebury College	Women's Lacrosse	English	3.77
2014	Brianne Wiemann	Wesleyan University	Women's Rowing	Biology	4.00
2014	Jacob Tamposi	Williams College	Men's Swimming and Diving	Math and Economics	3.97
2016	Evie Keating	Middlebury College	Women's Lacrosse	Conservation Biology	3.79
2016	Tyler Olney	Tufts University	Men's Lacrosse	Mechanical Engineering	3.85
2017	Tobias Mullers	Williams College	Men's Indoor Track	Chemistry	3.90
2017	Vlad Murad	Colby College	Men's Tennis	Computer Science and Math	3.98
2018	Carter Hawthorne	Wesleyan University	Men's Lacrosse	Economics and Psychology	3.84
2018	Christinia Puccinelli	Middlebury College	Women's Tennis	Mathematics	4.00
2018	Meghan Sullivan	Amherst College	Women's Basketball	Math	3.98
2018	Sophia Shoulson	Wesleyan University	Women's Rowing	German Studies	4.00
2019	Jackson Herrick	Amherst College	Men's Lacrosse	Economics and Computer Science	3.98
2021	Isaac Gorelik	Tufts University	Men's Tennis	Data Science and Applied Mathematics	3.98
2022	Julia Meehan	Wesleyan University	Women's Soccer	Economics	4.00
2023	Cody Wiebe	Tufts University	Men's Lacrosse	Mechanical Engineering	4.00
2023	Hope Shue	Middlebury College	Women's Lacrosse	Neuroscience	4.00
2023	Meg Shelburne	Middlebury College	Field Hockey	History and Political Science	4.00
2024	Eleanor McGrath	Colby College	Women's Swimming and Diving	Environmental Science	4.00
2024	Hope Shue	Middlebury College	Women's Lacrosse	Neuroscience	4.00
2024	Gavin Randolph	Middlebury College	Men's Soccer	Computer Science and Economics	4.00
2025	Hope Shue	Middlebury College	Women's Lacrosse	Neuroscience	4.00
2025	Samuel Norris	Trinity College	Men's Basketball	Economics	3.97
2026	Nicola Donlan	Tufts University	Women's Lacrosse	Cognitive Brain Science	4.00