Total: 158
- Amherst (8), Bowdoin (38), Colby (18), Conn. College (1), Hamilton (15), Middlebury (40), Trinity (19), Tufts (1), Wesleyan (6), Williams (12)
Most In a Single Season: 6 (2004-05 & 2013-14)
Source: AHCA All-American Archive
 

Year	Name	Institution	Position
1969-70	Edward Good	Bowdoin	Forward
1969-70	John Bradley	Bowdoin	Goalie
1969-70	Robert Hall	Bowdoin	Defense
1969-70	Todd Smith	Colby	Defense
1969-70	Michael Thomas	Hamilton	Forward
1969-70	Gary Bensen	Williams	Forward
1970-71	Bob Kullen	Bowdoin	Defense
1971-72	Steve Self	Colby	Forward
1972-73	Dick Donovan	Bowdoin	Forward
1974-75	John Bigneron	Bowdoin	Defense
1974-75	Jim Brimsek	Middlebury	Goalie
1975-76	Kurt Ziemendorf	Hamilton	Defense
1975-76	Rick Zeller	Williams	Defense
1977-78	Bob Devaney	Bowdoin	Forward
1977-78	Gerry Ciarcia	Bowdoin	Defense
1978-79	Gerry Ciarcia	Bowdoin	Defense
1979-80	Mark Pletts	Bowdoin	Defense
1980-81	Bill Provencher	Bowdoin	Goalie
1981-82	Jean Roy	Bowdoin	Defense
1982-83	Chris Simon	Bowdoin	Forward
1982-83	Jean Roy	Bowdoin	Defense
1983-84	Chris Simon	Bowdoin	Forward
1983-84	Jean Roy	Bowdoin	Defense
1985-86	Jon Leonard	Bowdoin	Defense
1985-86	Walter Edwards	Colby	Goalie
1985-86	Arthur Fitzgerald	Trinity	Goalie
1986-87	John McGeough	Bowdoin	Forward
1986-87	Jon Leonard	Bowdoin	Defense
1986-87	Vin Paolucci	Colby	Forward
1988-89	Brendan Hickey	Bowdoin	Forward
1988-89	Kevin Potter	Bowdoin	Defense
1988-89	Guy Hebert	Hamilton	Goalie
1988-89	Harry McCabe	Hamilton	Forward
1989-90	Brad Chin	Bowdoin	Forward
1990-91	Brent Truchon	Middlebury	Goalie
1990-91	Doug Cochran	Middlebury	Forward
1990-91	Marc Alcindor	Middlebury	Forward
1991-92	Derek Bettencourt	Colby	Forward
1991-92	Brent Truchon	Middlebury	Goalie
1991-92	Doug Cochran	Middlebury	Defense
1991-92	Kent Hughes	Middlebury	Forward
1991-92	Pat Currie	Middlebury	Defense
1992-93	Charlie Gaffney	Bowdoin	Forward
1992-93	Neil Sinclair	Middlebury	Defense
1992-93	Ray Alcindor	Middlebury	Forward
1992-93	Marc Siegel	Williams	Goalie
1993-94	Charlie Gaffney	Bowdoin	Forward
1993-94	Paul Croteau	Bowdoin	Defense
1993-94	Marc Siegel	Williams	Goalie
1993-94	Mark Yannetti	Williams	Defense
1994-95	Charlie Gaffney	Bowdoin	Forward
1994-95	Paul Croteau	Bowdoin	Defense
1994-95	Francois Bourbeau	Middlebury	Goalie
1994-95	Ian Smith	Middlebury	Defense
1994-95	Marc Siegel	Williams	Goalie
1995-96	Stu Logan	Bowdoin	Goalie
1995-96	Brian Cronin	Colby	Forward
1995-96	Ian Smith	Middlebury	Defense
1995-96	Sebastidn Bilodeau	Middlebury	Defense
1996-97	Dan Lavergne	Colby	Forward
1996-97	Rob Koh	Colby	Defense
1996-97	Joe Baudo	Hamilton	Defense
1996-97	Chris Farion	Middlebury	Goalie
1996-97	Sebastien Bilodeau	Middlebury	Defense
1997-98	Rob Koh	Colby	Defense
1997-98	Francois Bourbeau	Middlebury	Goalie
1997-98	Mark Spence	Middlebury	Forward
1997-98	Ryan Goldman	Middlebury	Defense
1998-99	Rob MacDonald	Amherst	Forward
1998-99	Rob Koh	Colby	Defense
1998-99	Ben Barnett	Middlebury	Defense
1998-99	John Giannacopoulos	Middlebury	Forward
1998-99	David Haimson	Williams	Goalie
1999-00	Ben Barnett	Middlebury	Defense
1999-00	Curt Goldman	Middlebury	Forward
1999-00	John Giannacopoulos	Middlebury	Forward
1999-00	David Haimson	Williams	Goalie
2000-01	Jim Smith	Amherst	Defense
2000-01	Matt Skoglund	Middlebury	Defense
2000-01	Scott Goldman	Middlebury	Forward
2001-02	Mike Carosi	Bowdoin	Forward
2001-02	Christian Carlsson	Middlebury	Goalie
2001-02	Kevin Cooper	Middlebury	Forward
2001-02	Matt Dunn	Middlebury	Defense
2001-02	Ryan Constantine	Middlebury	Defense
2002-03	Kevin Cooper	Middlebury	Forward
2002-03	Doug Kiselius	Trinity	Goalie
2003-04	Kevin Cooper	Middlebury	Forward
2004-05	Beau Kretzman	Amherst	Forward
2004-05	Patrick Walsh	Colby	Defense
2004-05	Gus Katsuras	Hamilton	Forward
2004-05	Brian Phinney	Middlebury	Defense
2004-05	Doug Kiselius	Trinity	Goalie
2004-05	Joseph Ori	Trinity	Forward
2005-06	George Papachristopoulos	Bowdoin	Goalie
2005-06	Jon Landry	Bowdoin	Defense
2005-06	Gus Katsuras	Hamilton	Forward
2005-06	Jeff Smith	Middlebury	Defense
2005-06	Mickey Gilchrist	Middlebury	Forward
2006-07	Arthur Fritch	Colby	Defense
2006-07	Greg Osborne	Colby	Forward
2006-07	Tom Maldonado	Middlebury	Defense
2006-07	John Halverson	Trinity	Defense
2007-08	Mike Westerman	Bowdoin	Defense
2007-08	Arthur Fritch	Colby	Defense
2007-08	T.J. Kelly	Colby	Forward
2007-08	Tom Maldonado	Middlebury	Defense
2008-09	Cole Anderson	Amherst	Goalie
2008-09	Jeff Landers	Amherst	Defense
2008-09	Jamie McKenna	Middlebury	Forward
2009-10	Kyle Shearer-Hardy	Bowdoin	Defense
2009-10	Martin Drolet	Middlebury	Forward
2009-10	Scott Barchard	Tufts	Goalie
2009-10	Alex Smigelski	Williams	Forward
2010-11	Kyle Shearer-Hardy	Bowdoin	Defense
2010-11	Joe Houk	Hamilton	Defense
2011-12	Jonathan LaRose	Amherst	Goalie
2011-12	Jordan Lalor	Bowdoin	Defense
2011-12	Justin Troiani	Williams	Defense
2012-13	Timothy McGarry	Bowdoin	Defense
2012-13	Keith Buehler	Wesleyan	Forward
2013-14	Colin Downey	Bowdoin	Defense
2013-14	Louis Belisle	Middlebury	Defense
2013-14	Jackson Brewer	Trinity	Forward
2013-14	Michael Flynn	Trinity	Defense
2013-14	Michael Hawkrigg	Trinity	Forward
2013-14	Sean Dougherty	Williams	Goalie
2014-15	Jake Turrin	Amherst	Defense
2014-15	Michael Flynn	Trinity	Defense
2014-15	Michael Hawkrigg	Trinity	Forward
2014-15	Nathaniel Heilbron	Trinity	Goalie
2014-15	Ryan Cole	Trinity	Forward
2015-16	Sean Orlando	Trinity	Forward
2015-16	Zander Masucci	Williams	Defense
2016-17	Evan Buitenhuis	Hamilton	Goalie
2017-18	Connor Rodericks	Conn. College	Goalie
2017-18	Evan Buitenhuis	Hamilton	Goalie
2018-19	Phil Johansson	Amherst	Defense
2018-19	Michael Grande	Trinity	Defense
2018-19	Tim Sestak	Wesleyan	Goalie
2018-19	Walker Harris	Wesleyan	Forward
2019-20	Barclay Gammill	Trinity	Forward
2019-20	Michael Grande	Trinity	Defense
2019-20	Walker Harris	Wesleyan	Forward
2021-22	Andy Beran	Colby	Goalie
2021-22	Jack Sullivan	Colby	Defense
2021-22	Lucas Michaud	Trinity	Forward
2022-23	Jack Sullivan	Colby	Defense
2022-23	Jake Lachance	Wesleyan	Defense
2022-23	Wiggle Kerbrat	Wesleyan	Forward
2023-24	James Philpott	Hamilton	Defense
2023-24	Devon Bobak	Trinity	Goalie
2023-24	Ned Blanchard	Trinity	Defense
2024-25	Charlie Archer	Hamilton	Goalie
2024-25	James Philpott	Hamilton	Defense
2024-25	Luke Tchor	Hamilton	Forward
2025-26	Jacob Osborne	Bowdoin	Goalie
2025-26	Luke Tchor	Hamilton	Forward