Total (since founding of NESCAC in 1971): 18
Source: AP Little All-America Archive (courtesy of East Stroudsburg Athletics)
 

Year	Name	School	Team
1972	Phil Pope	Middlebury	3rd
1984	Tim McNamara	Trinity	2nd
1986	Joe Gilbert	Hamilton	3rd
1990	Ted Rogers	Williams	2nd
1994	Greg Schramm	Trinity	3rd
1995	Ethan Brooks	Williams	3rd
2000	Andy Steele	Middlebury	3rd
2002	Scott Farley	Williams	3rd
2003	Graham Goldwasser	Williams	2nd
2003	Jared Carillo	Trinity	3rd
2005	Michael Blair	Trinity	3rd
2010	Henry Melendez	Trinity	1st
2014	Joe Magardino	Trinity	3rd
2015	Sam Hart	Amherst	2nd
2024	Ty Richardson	Tufts	2nd
2025	Dylan Connors	Wesleyan	1st
2025	Angus Leary	Bowdoin	3rd
2025	Owen Thornton	Middlebury	3rd