Total: 253 (all-time) / 179 (from the first season of the conference in 1972-73 academic year)
- Amherst (51), Bates (2), Bowdoin (19), Colby (7), Conn. College (5), Hamilton (3), Middlebury (43), Trinity (24), Tufts (19), Wesleyan (19), Williams (61)
Most in a Single Season: 7 (1983, 1999, 2007)
Source: United Soccer Coaches Almanac
 

Year	School	Name	Team
1941	Amherst	Jim Chapman	2nd
1941	Amherst	Ted Heisler	1st
1942	Amherst	Huitreit	2nd
1942	Williams	Thompson	HM
1946	Tufts	Richlieu Morris	HM
1947	Amherst	Ben Stolzfus	2nd
1947	Trinity	Godfrey Nelson	HM
1947	Wesleyan	Henri Salun	HM
1948	Amherst	Ben Stolzfus	1st
1948	Trinity	E. Nelson	HM
1948	Trinity	Godfrey Nelson	HM
1948	Wesleyan	Henri Salun	2nd
1949	Amherst	Donald Dunbar	1st
1949	Trinity	Jay Geiger	HM
1949	Trinity	Godfrey Nelson	1st
1949	Trinity	Robert Wood	HM
1950	Amherst	Howard Burnett	2nd
1951	Amherst	Howard Burnett	HM
1951	Amherst	James Fernandes	HM
1951	Hamilton	Phillip Hills	HM
1951	Trinity	Robert Almquist	HM
1952	Trinity	George Lunt	HM
1952	Trinity	Neil Mutschler	HM
1952	Williams	Paul Quinn	HM
1953	Amherst	Charles Rogers	HM
1953	Trinity	Winfield Carlough	1st
1953	Trinity	Neil Mutschler	1st
1953	Trinity	Arthur O'Connell	HM
1953	Wesleyan	Henry Ford	1st
1955	Amherst	E.C. Kirk Hall	1st
1955	Trinity	Kenneth Swanson	HM
1955	Williams	James Davie	HM
1955	Williams	Thomas Lincoln	2nd
1956	Trinity	Donald Duff	HM
1956	Trinity	Douglas Raynard	1st
1956	Trinity	Brendan Shea	HM
1957	Trinity	Brendan Shea	HM
1958	Amherst	Thomas Richardson	HM
1958	Amherst	Donald Sykes	HM
1958	Trinity	Alex Guild	2nd
1958	Trinity	Brendan Shea	HM
1959	Amherst	Andrew Mallory	HM
1959	Trinity	Alex Guild	2nd
1960	Amherst	Andrew Mallory	2nd
1960	Middlebury	Tor Hultgren	HM
1960	Trinity	Alex Guild	HM
1961	Amherst	Tony Scolnick	HM
1961	Middlebury	D. Van Winkle	HM
1961	Williams	Alvord Rutherford	1st
1962	Hamilton	Donald McCouch	2nd
1962	Middlebury	Keith Van Winkle	1st
1962	Middlebury	D. Van Winkle	HM
1962	Wesleyan	Brian Sharp	HM
1962	Williams	J. O'Donnell	2nd
1963	Middlebury	Keith Van Winkle	1st
1963	Middlebury	J. Davis Webb	HM
1964	Colby	David Kelly	HM
1964	Middlebury	J. Davis Webb	1st
1964	Trinity	Mark Josephson	HM
1965	Bates	Robert Thompson	HM
1965	Middlebury	David Nicholson	2nd
1965	Middlebury	J. Davis Webb	HM
1966	Amherst	Jaffer Kassamali	1st
1966	Middlebury	John Garrison	1st
1966	Middlebury	Peter Kovner	2nd
1966	Williams	Jonathan Healy	HM
1967	Amherst	Jaffer Kassamali	2nd
1967	Amherst	Cleanthis Nicolaidis	2nd
1967	Middlebury	John Marks	1st
1967	Williams	Jonathan Healy	2nd
1968	Amherst	Mark Coffin	HM
1968	Middlebury	Keith Conners	HM
1971	Tufts	Gabriel Gomez	2nd
1971	Wesleyan	Marion Stoj	HM
1972	Williams	John H. Buehler	HM
1973	Tufts	Dale Graden	HM
1973	Wesleyan	Marion Stoj	2nd
1976	Bowdoin	James E. Quinlan	HM
1978	Williams	Gregg S. Harman	HM
1980	Wesleyan	Kofi Appenteng	HM
1981	Amherst	Robert Philbrick	1st
1981	Bowdoin	Keith Brown	1st
1981	Bowdoin	Kwame Poku	1st
1981	Middlebury	W. Jamie Hutchens	1st
1981	Middlebury	Mike Noonan	1st
1981	Wesleyan	Seth Sholes	3rd
1982	Amherst	Timothy Stephens	2nd
1982	Middlebury	Mike Noonan	1st
1982	Williams	Rob Kusel	HM
1983	Amherst	Douglas Lyons	3rd
1983	Amherst	Timothy Stephens	2nd
1983	Colby	Mark Burke	2nd
1983	Middlebury	Bart Lombardi	2nd
1983	Middlebury	Francis Nugent	2nd
1983	Wesleyan	John Nathan	1st
1983	Williams	Jeffrey McEvoy	2nd
1984	Amherst	Graham Sellers	3rd
1984	Amherst	Timothy Stephens	1st
1984	Colby	Mark Burke	1st
1984	Middlebury	Martin Wenthe	2nd
1984	Williams	Jeffrey McEvoy	1st
1985	Amherst	Douglas Lyons	2nd
1985	Colby	Mark Burke	1st
1985	Middlebury	Van Dorsey	3rd
1985	Williams	Jeffrey McEvoy	1st
1986	Amherst	Thomas Little	1st
1986	Middlebury	Christopher Parsons	1st
1986	Williams	Michael Masters	2nd
1987	Amherst	Edwin Rigaud	1st
1987	Middlebury	Marc Hirschfield	2nd
1987	Williams	Daniel Calichman	1st
1987	Williams	Michael Masters	1st
1988	Williams	Robert Blanck	1st
1988	Williams	Daniel Calichman	2nd
1988	Williams	Michael Masters	1st
1989	Williams	Daniel Calichman	1st
1989	Williams	Andrew Stern	3rd
1990	Colby	Brian Wiercinski	2nd
1990	Wesleyan	Vezir Ajro	2nd
1990	Williams	Robert Lake	1st
1991	Wesleyan	Vezir Ajro	1st
1991	Wesleyan	Dan Craig	2nd
1991	Williams	Orjan Hult	1st
1992	Middlebury	John Atherton	1st
1992	Wesleyan	Amos Magee	2nd
1993	Colby	Patrick Skulley	1st
1993	Williams	Jim Reidy	2nd
1994	Tufts	Erik Anderson	2nd
1994	Williams	John Thompson	1st
1995	Amherst	Mario Watts	2nd
1995	Middlebury	Cullen Meade	2nd
1995	Williams	Terry Kaufman	1st
1995	Williams	Brad Murray	1st
1995	Williams	Peter Rogaris	2nd
1996	Middlebury	Michael Taylor	2nd
1996	Tufts	Chris Vriavas	3rd
1996	Williams	Brad Murray	1st
1997	Amherst	Tim Christian	2nd
1997	Bowdoin	David DeCew	3rd
1997	Colby	Graham Nelson	2nd
1997	Tufts	Matt Adler	2nd
1997	Williams	Greg Classen	1st
1997	Williams	Nikolai Nachamkin	1st
1998	Amherst	Matt Diggs	1st
1998	Bowdoin	David DeCew	1st
1998	Middlebury	John Giannacopoulos	2nd
1998	Middlebury	Ben Hardy	1st
1998	Williams	Stephen Danbusky	1st
1998	Williams	Nick Trebat	2nd
1999	Amherst	Andy Kay	3rd
1999	Bates	Andy Apstein	1st
1999	Middlebury	John Giannacopoulos	2nd
1999	Trinity	Dan Rudolph	2nd
1999	Tufts	Matt Adler	3rd
1999	Williams	Ted Gianncoupolos	3rd
1999	Williams	Matthew Magiera	1st
2000	Williams	Alex Blake	1st
2000	Williams	Ted Gianncoupolos	1st
2000	Williams	Josef Powell	1st
2001	Bowdoin	David Bulow	3rd
2001	Williams	Alex Blake	1st
2001	Williams	Ted Gianncoupolos	1st
2001	Williams	Josef Powell	1st
2001	Williams	Marc Williams	3rd
2002	Williams	Alex Blake	1st
2002	Williams	Khari Stephenson	1st
2003	Amherst	Franklin Perry	2nd
2003	Bowdoin	Dan Sullivan	1st
2003	Middlebury	Jason Griffiths	1st
2003	Williams	Ryan Olsen	1st
2003	Williams	Khari Stephenson	1st
2004	Bowdoin	Dan Sullivan	1st
2004	Middlebury	John Rusten	2nd
2004	Williams	Josh Bolton	1st
2005	Bowdoin	Mike Crowley	3rd
2005	Middlebury	Derek Cece	3rd
2005	Williams	Josh Bolton	1st
2005	Williams	Dana Leary	1st
2006	Amherst	Mike Wohl	2nd
2006	Bowdoin	Nick Figueiredo	3rd
2006	Hamilton	Greg Rogan	3rd
2006	Wesleyan	Jared Ashe	2nd
2006	Williams	Patrick Huffer	1st
2006	Williams	Dana Leary	1st
2007	Amherst	Taylor Downs	2nd
2007	Amherst	Grayson Holland	3rd
2007	Bowdoin	Nick Figueiredo	1st
2007	Middlebury	Brian Bush	1st
2007	Middlebury	Alex Elias	1st
2007	Middlebury	Casey Ftorek	1st
2007	Middlebury	Andrew Germansky	2nd
2008	Amherst	Grayson Holland	3rd
2008	Middlebury	Brian Bush	1st
2009	Amherst	Matt Lewis	3rd
2009	Middlebury	Harrison Watkins	1st
2009	Trinity	Peter Marlette	2nd
2009	Wesleyan	Adam Purdy	3rd
2009	Wesleyan	Woody Redpath	2nd
2009	Williams	Conor Smith	1st
2010	Bowdoin	Sean Bishop	1st
2010	Middlebury	Tim Cahill	2nd
2010	Middlebury	Harrison Watkins	1st
2010	Williams	Charles Romero	3rd
2010	Williams	Joe Vella	2nd
2011	Wesleyan	Rory O'Neill	2nd
2011	Williams	Phillip Vestergaard	2nd
2012	Amherst	Julien Aoyama	1st
2012	Amherst	Spencer Noon	1st
2012	Wesleyan	Rory O'Neill	3rd
2012	Williams	Peter Christman	3rd
2013	Amherst	Julien Aoyama	2nd
2013	Amherst	Thomas Bull	2nd
2013	Bowdoin	Ben Brewster	1st
2013	Williams	Matt Murralles	3rd
2014	Middlebury	Greg Conrad	3rd
2014	Tufts	Sam Williams	3rd
2014	Wesleyan	Ben Bratt	3rd
2015	Amherst	Thomas Bull	3rd
2015	Amherst	Nino Pascual-Leone	2nd
2015	Middlebury	Deklan Robinson	1st
2016	Amherst	Bryce Ciambella	3rd
2016	Tufts	Gaston Becherano	3rd
2017	Tufts	Conor Coleman	1st
2017	Tufts	Tyler Kulcsar	3rd
2018	Bowdoin	Moctar Niang	3rd
2018	Conn. College	AJ Marcucci	1st
2018	Tufts	Joe Braun	1st
2019	Amherst	German Giammattei	1st
2019	Conn. College	AJ Marcucci	1st
2019	Tufts	Joe Braun	1st
2019	Tufts	Gavin Tasker	2nd
2019	Williams	Demian Gass	3rd
2021	Amherst	German Giammattei	1st
2021	Bowdoin	Drake Byrd	2nd
2021	Tufts	Calvin Aroh	1st
2022	Amherst	Ada Okorogheye	1st
2022	Bowdoin	Julian Juantorena	3rd
2022	Bowdoin	Dylan Reid	1st
2022	Williams	Nick Boardman	3rd
2023	Amherst	Ada Okorogheye	3rd
2023	Conn. College	Matt Scoffone	3rd
2023	Middlebury	Luke Madden	2nd
2023	Tufts	Max Clivio	1st
2024	Amherst	Mohammed Nuhu	4th
2024	Bowdoin	Tyler Huck	4th
2024	Conn. College	Matt Scoffone	4th
2024	Middlebury	Luke Madden	1st
2024	Tufts	Max Clivio	1st
2024	Williams	Ben Diffley	4th
2025	Bowdoin	Tyler Huck	3rd
2025	Tufts	Bijan Akhtarzandi-Das	4th
2025	Conn. College	Max Haberman	4th
2025	Tufts	Xavier Canfin	4th