All-Time Total: 50
- Amherst (6), Bates (1), Bowdoin (1), Hamilton (3), Middlebury (5), Trinity (11), Tufts (8), Wesleyan (6), Williams (9)
Most in a Single Season: 5 (2024)
 

Year	School	Player Name
1969	Williams	Jack Maitland
1970	Trinity	David Kiarsis
1972	Amherst	Richard Murphy
1972	Wesleyan	Robert Heller
1973	Amherst	Fred Scott
1973	Wesleyan	Robert Heller
1974	Williams	John Chandler
1976	Tufts	Tim Whelan
1976	Wesleyan	John McVicar
1977	Bowdoin	Steve McCabe
1977	Wesleyan	John McVicar
1978	Trinity	Pat McNamara
1978	Tufts	Mark Buben
1978	Williams	Gregg McAleenan
1979	Tufts	Chris Connors
1980	Tufts	Mike Brown
1981	Bates	Larry DiGiammarino
1983	Middlebury	Jonathan Good
1986	Hamilton	Joe Gilbert
1986	Tufts	Bob Patz
1990	Williams	Geroge Rogers
1991	Hamilton	Eric Grey
1993	Trinity	Eric Mudry
1994	Williams	Bobby Walker
1995	Williams	Ethan Brooks
1996	Amherst	Alex Bernstein
1997	Amherst	Devin Moriarity
1999	Wesleyan	Matt Perceval
2000	Middlebury	Andy Steele
2002	Williams	Scott Farley
2003	Trinity	Jared Carillo
2003	Williams	Graham Goldwasser
2005	Trinity	Michael Blair
2008	Williams	John Szawlowski
2010	Trinity	Mike Melendex
2012	Middlebury	Billy Chapman
2014	Trinity	Joe Magardino
2015	Amherst	Sam Hart
2016	Trinity	Chris Simmons
2017	Trinity	Chris Simmons
2018	Amherst	Andrew Yamin
2022	Tufts	Phil Lutz
2023	Trinity	Matthew Jumes
2023	Tufts	Travis Cepalia
2024	Hamilton	Tighe Hoey
2024	Middlebury	Thomas Perry
2024	Middlebury	Tomas Kenary
2024	Trinity	Matthew Jumes
2024	Tufts	Ty Richardson
2025	Wesleyan	Dylan Connors