All-Time Champions
Middlebury: 10 (03-12-13-14-17-18-19-21-22-23)
Bowdoin: 8 (00-05-06-07-08-10-11-15)
Tufts: 3 (09-16-24)
Williams: 3 (01-02-04)
Bates: 1 (2025)
| Year |
Champion |
Runner-Up |
Score |
Host |
| 2025 |
No. 3 Bates |
No. 4 Wesleyan |
2-0 |
Tufts |
| 2024 |
No. 3 Tufts |
No. 5 Bates |
1-0 (Tufts won shootout, 3-2) |
Middlebury |
| 2023 |
No. 1 Middlebury |
No. 4 Williams |
4-0 |
Middlebury |
| 2022 |
No. 1 Middlebury |
No. 2 Tufts |
2-0 |
Middlebury |
| 2021 |
No. 1 Middlebury |
No. 3 Bowdoin |
4-3 |
Middlebury |
| 2020 |
None Declared - 2020 Season was canceled due to COVID-19 |
| 2019 |
No. 1 Middlebury |
No. 2 Tufts |
3-2 (OT) |
Middlebury |
| 2018 |
No. 1 Middlebury |
No. 2 Tufts |
1-0 |
Middlebury |
| 2017 |
No. 1 Middlebury |
No. 5 Trinity |
5-0 |
Middlebury |
| 2016 |
No. 1 Tufts |
No. 4 Middlebury |
3-1 |
Tufts |
| 2015 |
No. 1 Bowdoin |
No. 2 Middlebury |
2-1 |
Bowdoin |
| 2014 |
No. 2 Middlebury |
No. 1 Bowdoin |
2-1 |
Bowdoin |
| 2013 |
No. 4 Middlebury |
No. 3 Bowdoin |
5-4 (OT) |
Amherst |
| 2012 |
No. 1 Middlebury |
No. 3 Bowdoin |
3-2
Middlebury wins on PS, 3-2 |
Middlebury |
| 2011 |
No. 1 Bowdoin |
No. 3 Middlebury |
2-1 |
Bowdoin |
| 2010 |
No. 2 Bowdoin |
No. 1 Tufts |
3-0 |
Tufts |
| 2009 |
No. 2 Tufts |
No. 1 Trinity |
3-2 |
Trinity |
| 2008 |
No. 2 Bowdoin |
No. 1 Tufts |
1-0 |
Tufts |
| 2007 |
No. 1 Bowdoin |
No. 3 Middlebury |
3-1 |
Bowdoin |
| 2006 |
No. 1 Bowdoin |
No. 2 Middlebury |
1-0 |
Bowdoin |
| 2005 |
No. 1 Bowdoin |
No. 3 Williams |
1-0
Bowdoin wins on PS, 4-2 |
Bowdoin |
| 2004 |
No. 3 Williams |
No. 1 Middlebury |
4-3 (OT) |
Middlebury |
| 2003 |
No. 1 Middlebury |
No. 3 Williams |
1-0 |
Middlebury |
| 2002 |
No. 2 Williams |
No. 1 Bowdoin |
2-1 |
Bowdoin |
| 2001 |
No. 3 Williams |
No. 4 Amherst |
3-0 |
Middlebury |
| 2000 |
No. 1 Bowdoin |
No. 3 Williams |
2-0 |
Bowdoin |
