| Year |
Champion |
Runner-Up |
|---|---|---|
| 2019 | Middlebury | Tufts |
| 2018 | Middlebury | Bowdoin |
| 2017 | Colby | Trinity |
| 2016 | Middlebury | Trinity |
| 2015 | Trinity | Bowdoin |
| 2014 | Trinity | Amherst |
| 2013 | Trinity | Middlebury |
| 2012 | Trinity | Middlebury |
| 2011 | Trinity | Colby |
| 2010 | Williams | Colby |
| 2009 | Colby | Williams |
| 2008 | Colby | Trinity |
| 2007 | Middlebury | Colby |
| 2006 | Middlebury | Bowdoin |
| 2005 | Middlebury | Amherst |
| 2004 | Middlebury | Amherst |
| 2003 | Middlebury | Amherst |
| 2002 | Middlebury | Amherst |
| 2001 | Middlebury | Amherst |
| All-Time Champions: Middlebury - 10, Trinity - 5, Colby - 3, Williams - 1 | ||